Optimal economic insulation thickness may be determined by various methods. Two of these are the minimum-total-cost method and the incremental-cost method (or marginal-cost method). The minimum-total-cost method involves the actual calculations of lost energy and insulation costs for each insulation thickness. The thickness producing the lowest total cost is the optimal economic solution. The optimum thickness is determined to be the point where the last dollar invested in insulation results in exactly $1 in energy-cost savings ("ETI— Economic Thickness for Industrial Insulation," Conservation Pap. 46, Federal Energy Administration, August 1976). The incremental-cost method provides a simplified and direct solution for the least-cost thickness.
The total-cost method does not in general provide a satisfactory means for making most insulation investment decisions, since an economic return on investment is required by investors and the method does not properly consider this factor. Return on investment is considered by Rubin ("Piping Insulation—Economics and Profits," in Practical Considerations in Piping Analysis, ASME Symposium, vol. 69, 1982, pp. 27-46). The incremental method used in this reference requires that each incremental a in of insulation provide the predetermined return on investment. The minimum thickness of installed insulation is used as a base for calculations. The incremental installed capital cost for each additional a in of insulation is determined. The energy saved for each increment is then determined. The value of this energy varies directly with the temperature level [e.g., steam at 538° C (1000° F) has a greater value than condensate at 100° C (212° F)]. The final increment selected for use is required either to provide a satisfactory return on investment or to have a suitable payback period.
Recommended Thickness of Insulation Indoor insulation thickness appears in Table 11-21, and outdoor thickness appears in Table 11-22. These selections were based upon calcium silicate insulation with a suitable aluminum jacket. However, the variation in thickness for fiberglass, cellular glass, and rock wool is minimal. Fiberglass is available for maximum temperatures of 260, 343, and 454°C (500, 650, and 850° F). Rock wool, cellular glass, and calcium silicate are used up to 649°C (1200° F).
Was this article helpful?